top of page
jasper_logo_positive.png

Why Anticipatory Grief Feels Like an Emotional Roller Coaster

Writer: Jenn Roedig, DVM
Jenn Roedig, DVM
Jul 14, 2025
4 min read

Updated: Sep 29

One of the most disorienting things about anticipatory pet loss grief is how contradictory it can feel. You might wake up feeling relatively okay, and by evening you are undone. You might feel deep gratitude for a good day with your pet and then spiral into panic an hour later about how many good days might be left. You might feel hope when they seem stronger, then guilt for having felt hope at all.


This emotional whiplash is exhausting. And it can make you feel like something is fundamentally unstable about the way you are coping. What is actually happening is more understandable than that, and knowing why this occurs can take some of the weight off the experience.



Why the "In-Between" Space Is So Hard

Anticipatory grief places you in a state of sustained tension that has no clean resolution. You are loving your pet as fully as you can while simultaneously bracing for a loss that has not yet arrived. Your brain is doing two things at once: trying to stay present with your pet, in the current moment, with the love you have right now, and trying to prepare for a future where they are gone.


Those two impulses are in direct conflict. Staying present requires openness and allowing yourself to feel the joy and intimacy of what is still here. Preparing for loss requires a kind of protective withdrawal, an attempt to pre-process the pain before it arrives. Your mind cannot do both of those things at the same time, and so it cycles between them, sometimes rapidly, which is what produces the feeling of being on a roller coaster.


That cycling is not dysfunction. It is your mind and nervous system doing their best to navigate an inherently impossible situation.



Why Guilt Keeps Showing Up

Guilt is one of the most commonly reported emotions in anticipatory pet loss grief, and it tends to arrive in a few predictable forms. You might feel guilty for thinking about the end when your pet is still here, as though thinking it might somehow make it happen. You might feel guilty for experiencing relief on a good day, worried that relief means you have quietly accepted what is coming. You might feel guilty for the moments when you feel okay, as if feeling okay is a form of disloyalty.


None of these guilt experiences mean you are doing anything wrong. They are a reflection of how much you love your pet and how desperately you want to get this right. The fact that you feel guilt at all is evidence of how carefully you are paying attention. What guilt in anticipatory grief rarely reflects is actual failure. It usually reflects love combined with fear.



The Specific Weight of Not Knowing

Part of what makes anticipatory grief particularly hard to navigate is the uncertainty at its center. You do not know exactly when, or how, or what it will look like, or whether you will know when the time comes to make a decision. Living inside that uncertainty, day after day, takes a real toll, and it is one that is difficult to explain to people who are not inside it with you.


The waiting is its own kind of grief. Every good day carries the awareness that it is one of a finite number of good days. Every difficult day carries the fear that this is the beginning of the end. The in-between space is genuinely stressful, and the emotional oscillation it produces is a direct response to that stress, not a sign that something is wrong with your capacity to cope.

What Helps When the Emotions Feel Unmanageable

When you are in an emotionally flooded moment, one of the most useful things you can do is simply name what you are feeling rather than trying to fix it or reason your way out of it. "I am scared" or "I am cycling between hope and dread and I don't know how to sit with both" can bring a small amount of steadiness just by making the experience visible.


You are allowed to feel both the light and the heavy. You do not have to choose between being present with your pet and also grieving what is coming. Both can be true at the same time, and both deserve space.



-------

FAQs

Why do I feel okay one moment and devastated the next in anticipatory grief?

Anticipatory grief places you in a sustained tension between being present and bracing for loss. Your nervous system cycles between those two states, which produces emotional oscillation that can feel disorienting. This is a normal response to an inherently difficult situation.


Is it normal to feel guilty during anticipatory grief?

Yes. Guilt is extremely common in anticipatory grief and typically reflects deep love and a desire to do everything right, not actual failure. It often surfaces around thinking about the end, experiencing moments of relief, or feeling okay when you feel like you shouldn't.


Why does anticipatory grief feel so exhausting?

Because it requires sustained emotional labor with no clear endpoint. You are managing grief, love, fear, uncertainty, and the practical demands of caring for a sick pet, often all at once. The exhaustion is real and it makes sense.


Can anticipatory grief feel as intense as grief after loss?

Yes. For some people, anticipatory grief is as emotionally intense as post-loss grief. The experience varies widely. Either way, the intensity is a reflection of the bond, not a measure of whether you are coping well.


What helps with the emotional roller coaster of anticipatory grief?

Naming your emotions rather than judging them, finding support from people who understand anticipatory grief specifically, and building in small grounding practices for when the intensity spikes can all help. You do not have to manage this entirely on your own.

Dr. Jenn Roedig, DVM, is a veterinarian, end-of-life coach, and pet loss grief coach at Jasper.


If you are carrying this loss, you don't have to carry it alone. Jasper's community is a place where people who understand hold space for each other, with honesty and without judgment.



bottom of page